Bookmark and Share

The first intensive exploration of the unrecognized psychological and social aspects of this increasingly controversial American cultural practice. Endorsed by dozens of professionals in psychology, psychiatry, child development, pediatrics, obstetrics, childbirth education, sociology and anthropology.


What You Can Do

Consultation and Counseling

For circumcised men and expectant parents

Sign Our Petition

Urge media to tell the whole story!

Educate Yourself

Get books, DVDs, CDs, and more

Volunteer

Help protect the next generation

Tell a Friend About Us

And those who may have future children

Talk About Circumcision

Our tips can turn discomfort into power

"What's done to children, they will do to society."

Karl Menninger, psychiatrist

"Parents do not know what they are choosing, and physicians do not feel what they are doing."

Ronald Goldman, Ph.D., author

"In response to circumcision, the baby cries a helpless, panicky, breathless, high-pitched cry!...[or] lapses into a semi-coma. Both of these states...are abnormal states in the newborn."

Justin Call, M.D., pediatrician

"Doctors who circumcise are the most resistant to change. They will not admit that they made a critical mistake by amputating an important part of the penis."

Paul Fleiss, M.D., pediatrician

"In this case, the old dictum 'If it ain't broke, don't fix it' seems to make good sense."

Eugene Robin, M.D., professor

"A whole life can be shaped by an old trauma, remembered or not."

Lenore Terr, M.D., child psychiatrist

"If we are to have real peace, we must begin with the children."

Mahatma Gandhi

"We are interconnected. When a baby boy's sexuality is not safe, no one's sexuality is safe."

Ronald Goldman, Ph.D., author

More Ethical Questions About Circumcision

Why do some doctors and nurses refuse to participate in circumcisions?

1. How does our perception of the humanity, capabilities, sensitivities, and awareness of a newborn infant affect how we feel about the ethics of circumcision?

2. What is the experience of circumcision like for the newborn infant?

3. How do we feel applying the Golden Rule to circumcision?

4. If we do not recognize the harm of circumcision, does that mean it does not exist?

5. When doctors circumcise are they complying with their ethical principle, "First, do no harm"?

6. What if circumcision conflicts with fundamental ethical principles?

7. How may perceived quantitative factors (e.g., time involved, amount of cutting, etc.) affect ethical opinions regarding circumcision?

8. How could psychological resistance, circumcision status, and circumcision status of our children inhibit discussion of ethical considerations about circumcision?

9. How are ethical considerations about circumcision influenced by what is culturally and religiously acceptable?

10. How does the influence of secular and religious authorities affect how we feel about the ethics of circumcision?

11. Why do some doctors and nurses refuse to participate in circumcisions?

12. What ethical conflicts are leading more Jews, including rabbis, to question and forgo circumcision?

13. How do the feelings of dissatisfied circumcised men affect ethical considerations about circumcision?

14. What about the ethics of ignoring conflicts of interest of researchers and policy-makers, withholding information by media outlets, and preventing open debate about circumcision?

Ethical Questions

 

Circumcision Resource Center